Multivitamins for Better Health: Yes or No?

woman holding a multivitamin

Do you take a multivitamin every day to help improve your health? Or maybe you supplement your limited diet with powders and pills meant to fill in the gaps of a less-than-ideal eating plan. If your medicine cabinet contains an alphabet soup of vitamins and mineral supplements, you’re probably one of the millions of Americans who rely on bottled nutrition to help supply the building blocks for a healthy body and mind. But is that an effective game plan?

Not necessarily, according to Danielle Metzler, MD. She recommends a balanced diet for better health—not a trip to the pharmacy or vitamin store.

“The truth of the matter is that there’s not a lot of fact-based evidence that taking a vitamin supplement improves your health,” says Dr. Metzler, a primary care doctor with Roper St. Francis Physician Partners Primary Care. “A lot of these products don’t have to go through any kind of testing before they hit the market. The safest option is to improve your diet and talk to your doctor or nutritionist about how to get these micro and macronutrients into your diet.”

What are vitamins and minerals?

“In general, when people say vitamins or supplements, they’re using the terms interchangeably, or they’re talking about vitamins and minerals,” says Dr. Metzler. Minerals are inorganic elements that promote bone health, balance your body’s fluids and support growth. Vitamins are nutrients that help your body function properly. They are essential for various roles, including digestion, growth and regulating your body’s processes.

There are two main types of vitamins:

Multivitamins are supplements that consist of a variety of vitamins and minerals. Their ingredients and potency vary according to brand and product details. They come in many forms, including capsules, pills, gummies, liquids and powders. Multivitamins are not strictly regulated by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA). This means you can’t always be sure what they contain.

Who needs vitamin supplements?

There is no one-size-fits-all answer to know whether you might benefit from taking vitamins. “It’s not as simple as ‘Should I take a supplement, which one and why.’ It’s really an individualized thing, and folks should talk to their doctor about what’s right for them,” says Dr. Metzler. “If someone has a particular vitamin deficiency—like vitamin D or calcium, their electrolytes are off, or they’re low on zinc, something like that—that can be a marker that a doctor can test for.”

Your doctor takes your personal and family medical history into account when determining if you need extra vitamins. You may need to take a vitamin supplement if you:

Your doctor can help determine whether you need additional vitamins and minerals to achieve the health benefits you’re looking for.

Are there health risks associated with vitamin supplements?

The main risk associated with taking vitamins is taking too many. For example, fat-soluble vitamins can accumulate in your body if you consume excessive amounts. Overconsumption can lead to serious health concerns, including organ damage, stroke and irregular heartbeat. Water-soluble vitamins may not raise the same health alarms. Still, if you take more than the recommended dose, it may cause digestive upset, liver damage and neurological concerns.

Find a doctor

To find a primary care doctor who can help you develop a balanced eating plan that provides the vitamins and minerals you need to live your best life, call (843) 402-CARE or visit


7 responses to “Multivitamins for Better Health: Yes or No?”

  1. Good information. For us senior readers under the heading ‘What are vitamin’s and minerals ?
    We know more about water soluble vitamins but know little about fat soluble vitamins.
    We would appreciate a, “for instance in”, behind each letter such as vitamin K,E,D and A. I think many of us are over dosing because we have heard, “taking too much of anything just flushes out of your system” so to much is better than too little.

  2. It is a good question, one I have often asked myself. I opened your email as I wanted a ‘YES’ or NO answer. But I did not get it. I read the article and still did’t get a YES or NO answer.

  3. Your article on whether to take a vitamin and/or mineral supplement was informative. But your advice to find a PCP to help develop an eating plan should be corrected. Most PCPs are not trained in nutrition. The article should have advised a person to find a Registered Dietitian/Nutritionist. RSF has several RDNs that would be able to provide this assistance.

  4. Thanks for your comment! I am 71 year old male and very active (motion is lotion). I lift weights 3 days a week and surf on a regular basis! I also ride my bicycle a couple days a week. My wife is a nurse and she keeps us eating healthy and keeps me on the straight and narrow! Pastor BH Rader!

  5. I am 92 years old and considered to be in excellent health for my age. I was low on vitamin D but I increased my C & D vitamins. I know I should have a complete blood work up, my last one was a year ago, but with this covid outbreak again I am afraid to go to the Dr’s office. I did have both of my shots.
    what are your thoughts on what I should do?

    • Hi Mary, if you are not quite comfortable going into a doctor’s office yet, we do offer virtual visits. Check with your primary care doctor to see if a virtual visit is offered. Your primary care doctor can ask a series of questions and order blood work. We hope this helps. However, please call 402-2273 if you have any further questions.

%d bloggers like this: